Bye, Sofía Vergara? Meet Joe Manganiello's new girlfriend, Caitlin

Joe Manganiello goes Instagram official with Caitlin O'Connor

Following his split from Sofía Vergara, Joe Manganiello attended

Joe Manganiello Dates Caitlin O'Connor After Meeting in a Hot Tub

Caitlin Magadieu Facebook, Instagram & Twitter on PeekYou

Joe Manganiello and girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor move in together

Joe Manganiello Met Rumored Girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor in a Hot Tub

Bye, Sofía Vergara? Meet Joe Manganiello's new girlfriend, Caitlin

Joe Manganiello Makes New Relationship Instagram Official After

Sofía Vergara didn't want to be an 'old mom' in Joe Manganiello

Joe Manganiello Steps Out with Girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor Amid Ex

Joe Manganiello Won Over By Caitlin O'Connor's Sense Of Humor

Joe Manganiello 'Excited' For Future With Girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor

Joe Manganiello, 47, Ready for Baby With GF Caitlin O'Connor, 34