Joe Manganiello & Girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor Are Going Strong

Photos for: Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O

Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O'Connor move in together,…

Just Jared: Celebrity Gossip and Breaking Entertainment News

Joe Manganiello has 'moved on' with Caitlin O'Connor

Joe Manganiello & Girlfriend Caitlin O'Connor Are Going Strong

Joe Manganiello Has a New Girlfriend and They Met in a Hot Tub

Joe Manganiello and Caitlin O'Connor laugh at the Jets game

Joe Manganiello Goes Instagram Official With Girlfriend Caitlin O

Just Jared: Celebrity Gossip and Breaking Entertainment News

Joe Manganiello & Caitlin O'Connor Might Be Fast-Tracking Family Life

Joe Manganiello Makes Caitlin O'Connor Romance Instagram Official